SATs: Ignore school league tables, headteachers urge parents


CREDIT: This story was first seen in BBC News

Final year pupils sat a raft of tough new tests in the summer. Only 53% of pupils passed, compared to the 80% who passed less rigorous tests in 2015, BBC News reports.

Primary heads leader Russell Hobby said ministers had stressed the scale of the changes meant comparisons could not be drawn on previous years’ results.

The government said schools had responded well to the higher demands.

Pupils at 14,930 state primary schools sat the new national Sats tests in reading, writing and maths – the “Three-Rs”; they also sat a spelling and grammar test.

In the run up to and during the tests, teachers and heads across England complained that the new papers had been set at too high a level and that not enough information had been made available.

The government’s expectation is that 65% of pupils in each school should meet the new expected standard in the “Three Rs”.

In total, about 11,000 schools failed to meet this target.

However, the Department for Education (DfE) said schools that achieved sufficient progress scores in reading, writing and maths would not be considered to be failing.

It is not made clear how that progress is calculated.

It also said it would hold steady the number of schools deemed to be failing at a maximum of six per cent.

This year’s results show 665 schools (five per cent of the total) did not meet either target and will be targeted for intervention.

Conversely, just 47 schools saw all pupils reaching the expected standard in reading, writing and maths.

General secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, Mr Hobby, said: “The pass mark for the test was set at a ridiculously high level.

“We have just failed half the children in the country and yet Ofsted is saying nearly 90% of schools are good or outstanding.

“Pupils were doing what they should have been doing in the early years of secondary school. Some of the grammatical stuff was the same level as GCSE English.”

You might also like...  Research finds less academic students 'set up to fail'

He added: “This data is not worth the paper it is written on. The government itself has said that it cannot be used to trigger interventions in schools.

“This year we saw the Sats system descend into chaos and confusion.

“Delayed and obscure guidance, papers leaked online, mistakes in test papers and inconsistent moderation made this year unmanageable for school leaders, teachers, parents and pupils.”

But School Standards Minister Nick Gibb said the introduction of a new curriculum had raised expectations and ensured “pupils become more accomplished readers and are fluent in the basics of arithmetic, including times-tables, long division and fractions”.

“Many schools have responded well to this more rigorous curriculum, supporting their pupils to be leaving primary school better prepared for the demands of secondary school,” he said.

Last year, when four-fifths of school pupils reached the expected level, then known as Level 4C, ministers praised schools for “rising to the challenge of raised standards and expectations for all pupils”.

The data shows a continuing gender gap, with 57% of girls reaching the expected level in reading, writing and maths compared with 50% of boys.

And the most disadvantaged children fared far worse in these new tests, compared to their non-disadvantaged peers, than they did in the previous test with just 39% achieving the standard.

The government data also reveals regional differences, with London performing very strongly.

Of the 33 London boroughs, all but one (Enfield) was above the national average in terms of the expected standard in reading, writing and maths.

The five local authorities with the highest percentage of pupils making the grade:

  • Kensington and Chelsea 70%
  • Bromley67%
  • Richmond-upon-Thames 67%
  • Trafford 66%
  • Sutton 65%

The five local authorities with the lowest percentage of pupils making the grade:

  • Bedford 42%
  • Peterborough 43%
  • Luton 45%
  • Dorset 45%
  • Stoke-on-Trent 45%

Ludgvan School in Cornwall was the only school where more than 50% of students achieved a high score in reading and maths and were working at greater depth in writing.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.